Mohammed S. Alkhamali
2013
Twitter: @Alkhamali_M
Young
learners of a foreign language pass by different stages in their way of
mastering the language. Although there are different views about these stages,
they have something in common. i.e. the differentiation of the number of the
stages does not change the fact that the represented ideas are the same. The
period of each stage is determined by the level of the provided language and by
the learners' age. In the following, I will discuss some of the views about
such stages that are related to our context in terms of learners' age and level
of the language.
Piaget
divided the stages into two stages. The first one is called assimilation. It
describes the state when the action happens without any change in the learner's
behavior. An example from our context, as EFL, the use of an adjective to
describe a noun, the learner may use the same structure of his mother tongue that is N+adj. The second stage is called
accommodation. Where the learner in the same previous context learnt the use of
such function and use it in an appropriate way. (Cameron, L. 2001. P3)
In
contrast with Piaget view, Vygotsky considers learning as a social interaction.
He divided stages into two. The first where the learner of a foreign language
produces the language with a help of others, usually teachers, this stage is
called interpersonal. The other stage is called intrapersonal where the learner
becomes more independent and beings able to produce the language by himself.
(Grow, G. n d)
Tabors
and Snow (as cited in Phillip C. n d) identify four stages of acquiring a
second language as follows:
1- Home
language use, where the learner shows resistance for the new language by using
his first language.
2- Nonverbal period.
In this stage the learner realizes that his first language is not appropriate
to this context. He becomes silent and communicate using nonverbal means.
3- Telegraphic
and formulaic stage. In this stage the learner starts using the new language
but in ungrammatical / incomplete form.
4- Productive
language. In this stage learner starts to speak language relatively well with
producing new phrases as he learnt more vocabulary.
Krashen and Terrell ( as cited in
http://www.ascd.org) divided
the second language acquisition stages into five however, the stages start from
age of 0 month. We can adapt these stages to our context by starting the first
stage in the fourth primary grade as follows:
1- Preproduction.
In this stage the learner has no or minimal understanding of the new language.
He also nods by yes / no as a response. Instead of writing and speaking, he
draws and points.
2- Early
production. Here the learner starts responding using one or two words. He has a
limited understanding to the new language. He also uses the present form of
verbs.
3- Speech
emergence. In this stage the learner shows a good understanding and can produce
simple sentences however, he still makes errors in grammar and pronunciation.
4- Intermediate
fluency. The understanding of the second/foreign language increases and the
produced errors decreases.
5- Advanced
fluency. When the learner masters the language and become a native-like
speaker.
The
aforementioned views describe the same stages in a way or another. In the
following I will try to gather these views in three stages, with taking into
account the context of our situation where English is the foreign language and
the target group are the learners from the fourth primary grade to the third
intermediate grade. Different variables should also be taken into consideration
such as motivation towards learning a
new language, ability of pronouncing
sounds, their age …, as internal factors; curriculum level, teacher, the linguistic
background of the parents… , as external factors.
The
first stage is the pre-production. This stage shows a demonstration of the
first language use. Learners still use the first language due to the difficulty
in producing the new sounds and words, shyness of committing mistakes or the
stereotype about the foreign language in the society. Teachers in this stage
have to encourage learners by explaining ,in Arabic, the benefits of learning
English. Teachers also should be aware to the importance of positive
reinforcement as a way of increasing learners' motivation. Exposing learners to
the English is the best way to make them familiar with the new language and its
sound system. The learning in this stage focuses on sounds and simple
vocabulary. This stage, in my opinion, will not last for a long time as
learners in this age are eager to learn, less shy of committing errors and also
competitive.
The
early production stage is the second one. In this stage, learners start to use
their previous acquired knowledge in learning the new ones. Arabic still affect
learning and producing English. This can be seen in form of translating ideas
from Arabic to English. As the level of the language increases in terms of the
difficulty and the covered aspects and areas as well. This might inhabit some
learners from mastering these aspects especially grammar. As English being
considered as a foreign language in our context, lots of in-class practice is
needed to fulfill the communication need. Teachers in this stage should be more
tolerant with learners' mistakes to keep them on track of willingness to learn
the language. This tolerance can be seen as teachers emphasis on fluency rather
than accuracy. This stage will last for
a long period of time.
The
third stage is the fluent production. Reaching this stage in this short time
with such little exposing can be so difficult. We need well qualified teachers,
in terms of language and teaching, to teach the learners during the whole
grades. Also we need well planned and designed curriculum that is taking
learners needs and interests into account. We also need authentic communicative
situations that ensure language use outside the class.
To
sum up, stages of mastering English for young learners are differ is terms of
number and length depending on different factors. However, these stages follow
the same processes in a way or another. Learners start with fully use of their
native language instead of the target one. They then move to use the new
language with help of their teachers or parents. After that, they become fully
independent in producing the new language.
References
Cameron, L.
2001. Teaching Languages to Young Learners. Cambridge university
press.
Phillip C. n d. BECOMING BILINGUAL:FIRST
AND SECOND LANGUAGE ACQUISITION. Can be found on http://216.31.235.229/public/Education%20Binder%202012-2013/01%20Education/Dual%20langauge%20Learners/BECOMING%20BILINGUAL%20article.pdf